Page 3 - Outer Glow

Now, after you have done the Inner Shadow, don't click OK yet. Look on the left side of the menu again and find Outer Glow. This should be right under Inner Shadow. Now, use the settings in the image provided above, or simply use the text below!

Blending Mode: Normal
Opacity: 30%
Noise: 0%
Color: Left side, #4f4f4f
Technique: Softer
Spread: 17%
Size: 5px

Leave the rest as default.